I don't quite see how the choice of voting for a mayor who appoints a cabinet who make decisions with little reference to the full council differs in any real way for voting for councillors who then appoint a cabinet who make decisions with little reference to the full council. Both are fundamentally undemocratic.
This time I languished in apathy but am proud that Matt, in his first ever opportunity to vote, took the time to go to the polling station and spoil his paper by drawing a duck with a speech bubble explaining that both options are undemocratic. Now that's the way to spoil a ballot paper, I hope it catches on as a campaign.
So does it matter at all? I'm sure it does, There are some great things in Middlesbrough (as well as the people and the Transporter) - I love Mima and Temenos, they show a bit of ambition and a look to the future but bulldozing communities and leaving them as wastelands sends the opposite message.
In Redcar the council has done a great job in largely using EU money to completely regenerate the seafront. I've moved my business there and have THE most stunning view from a great office and that does make a difference to my business. But in carrying out the renovation they called the Beacon the "Vertical Pier" and alienated the vast majority of the local population who still want a traditional pier.
So local government are doing some genuinely great things but scoring huge own goals at the same time. I think it's indicative of a political class totally out of touch with the communities they aim to represent yet still showing that they do genuinely want to move those communities forward in positive way. That suggests there must be some way of reconnecting communities with well-intentioned local politicians, maybe the influence of party HQ's and spin doctors is the problem. What's the answer to that - if I had the answer I'd stand for mayor!
The biggest downside to all this in Redcar is the massive negative feeling the majority of the population have about the area, and that's not a feeling I get in Middlesbrough (at least away from the Riverside!). Lots of local people talk the place down in a self-fulfilling prophecy of doom, even slating the new seafront development which has attracted businesses (me for one) and tens of thousands of visitors.
That needs to change and there are people in Redcar trying to make a difference in many ways through getting business to work together and generate new business (our new BNI chapter for one), beach clean-ups, events, education and much more - there's a lot to be proud of. If you're not convinced come down the esplanade, it looks great, pop into the Palace Hub Gallery (it's better than Mima and largely features local artists), have an ice-cream at Archers or a lemon top at Pacittos and pop and see us if you fancy a cuppa and admire our view.
![]() |
| Copyright, David Laud, i2i Business Solutions LLP |





